The iShares Gold Trust, launched in January 2005, has established itself as a significant player in the world of exchange-traded funds (ETFs). With its debut on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol IAU just a week later, the fund has garnered considerable attention from investorsBy mid-2022, it had amassed a considerable size of $30.4 billion in assets, ranking as the 41st largest ETF in the United States and the second largest alternative investment ETF after SPDR Gold Trust (GLD), which had $63.7 billion in assets at that time.

However, the dynamics of the market shifted dramatically as of December 14, 2022, when reports indicated that the iShares Gold Trust's assets had declined to $26.257 billionThis marked a staggering decrease of $4.143 billion over just six months, equating to a decline of 13.63%. In stark contrast, major indices such as the S&P 500 and Nasdaq composite experienced growth during the same period, gaining 8.72% and 3.45%, respectively

Advertisements

The comparison paints a worrying picture for the iShares Gold Trust, as its performance trailed significantly behind broader market trends.

Perhaps even more perplexing is how the iShares Gold Trust’s performance has diverged from international gold prices during this timeframeData from the Choice financial terminal revealed that international gold prices only dipped by approximately 2.7%, a stark contrast to the ETF’s 13.63% declineConsidering that the iShares Gold Trust aims to reflect the price of the gold it holds (minus fees), this discrepancy raises questionsIf the underperformance is attributed to the strength of the dollar driven by ongoing Federal Reserve interest rate hikes, one must wonder why the ETF lags behind the international gold price performance.

Historically, fluctuations in gold prices are often tied closely to buying or selling activities within gold ETFs

Advertisements

For instance, significant sell-offs in ETF holdings tend to exert downward pressure on the price of gold, while rising ETF holdings usually coincide with rising gold pricesFrom the perspective of long-term trends, the price of gold surged from around $500 per ounce in 2006 to nearly $1,800 today, paralleling the rise in ETF holdings from 250 tons to approximately 1,350 tonsThis historical correlation highlights how intertwined ETF performance can be with gold prices.

The launch of gold ETFs back in the early 2000s sparked a global wave of investment enthusiasmAt that time, stocks were still recovering from the burst of the dot-com bubble, leading to a skeptical sentiment among investors regarding equity marketsGold emerged as a viable alternative, characterized by notably different risk-return attributes compared to traditional assets

Advertisements

Studies show that the correlation between gold and the U.Sstock market is significantly low, with a minimum correlation coefficient of 0.02, and it even dips to -0.01 with the Dow Jones Industrial AverageConversely, gold tends to correlate more highly with other commodities priced in dollars.

Given the circumstances surrounding the launch of gold ETFs, it was no surprise that they found favor among Wall Street investors when fears concerning stock market volatility were at a peakThe adoption of gold ETFs came with their own appeal—low entry barriers, strong liquidity, and ease of trading.

Interestingly, the iShares Gold Trust is indexed to the LBMA Gold Price PM USD, a benchmark that has performed relatively decently over the last year

• Liquidity Risks in the U.S. Treasury Market
• Contradictory Data Poses Challenge for the Fed
• Profit Pressures on Financial Payment Institutions
• The Peak of U.S. Inflation: An Ongoing Trade
• Outlook on Interest Rate Trends in China and the U.S.

Data from various reports show that in the past month, two months, three months, and year, the fund reported returns of 1.90%, 9.98%, 6.49%, and 1.72%, respectively, all showing positive growthExtending the timeframe to three and five years reveals even more impressive performance, with returns of 142.95% and 184.72% respectively.

Looking forward, the future performance of the iShares Gold Trust seems tightly bound to international gold pricesHowever, recent forecasts suggest that 2023 might not be a bullish year for goldConcerns muddy the waters for potential investors.

On December 14, analysts, including Bernard Dahdah from French Bank Société Générale, released their annual economic outlook for 2023. Their findings indicate that global growth is likely to slow down while inflation rises; nevertheless, the potential downturn for gold and silver seems to outweigh any possible benefits

With expectations for the U.Sreal interest rates to remain positive, precious metals may not attract the level of investment they require.

According to their report, although the Federal Reserve is expected to begin easing rates in 2023, the anticipated decline in inflation is set to outpace the rate cuts, keeping real rates positiveThis scenario may exert negative pressure on gold pricesFurthermore, with various Asian economies showing signs of recovery post-pandemic, any improvement in the global economy could bolster stock markets instead of precious metals, increasing the risk of poor trades for gold.

Additionally, sustained strong demand for physical gold alongside central banks’ ongoing purchases should help maintain gold prices above $1,600 per ounce